Opioids for chronic pain: a new clinical guideline from the VA and Department of Defense
A new clinical practice guideline regarding the use of opioids for chronic pain has been released by the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) and Department of Defense (DoD).
The evidence-based recommendations are intended for practitioners throughout the DoD and VA Health Care systems and were developed by the Opioid Therapy for Chronic Pain Work Group. The revised guideline serves as an update to the 2010 guideline by the VA and DoD.
The guideline “is intended to assist healthcare providers in all aspects of patient care, including, but not limited to, diagnosis, treatment, and follow-up,” according to the work group. “The system-wide goal of this guideline is to improve the patient’s health and well-being by providing evidence-based guidance to providers who are taking care of patients on or being considered for long-term opioid therapy.”
The work group developed 18 recommendations and graded each as “strong for” or “strong against,” with the exception of the use of multimodal pain care in Recommendation 18, which was graded as “weak for.”
A summary of the work group’s recommendations is as follows:
Initiation and continuation of opioids
| 1. Avoid initiation of long-term opioid therapy for chronic pain. Use alternatives to opioid therapy such as self-management strategies and other nonpharmacologic treatments. When pharmacologic therapies are used, initiate nonopioids over opioids. |
| 2. If prescribing opioid therapy for patients with chronic pain, a short duration is recommended. Note: Consideration of opioid therapy beyond 90 days requires reevaluation and discussion of risks and benefits with the patient. |
| 3. For patients currently on long-term opioid therapy, the VA and DoD recommends ongoing risk mitigation strategies (see Recommendations 7-9), assessment for opioid use disorder, and consideration for tapering when risks exceed benefits (see Recommendation 14). |
| 4. Avoid long-term opioid therapy for pain in patients with an untreated substance use disorder. For patients currently on long-term opioid therapy with evidence of an untreated substance use disorder, the VA and DoD suggest close monitoring, including engagement in substance use disorder treatment, and discontinuation of opioid therapy for pain with appropriate tapering (see Recommendations 14 and 17). |
| 5. Avoid the concurrent use of benzodiazepines and opioids. Note: For patients currently on long-term opioid therapy and benzodiazepines, consider tapering one or both when risks exceed benefits and obtaining specialty consultation as appropriate (see Recommendation 14 and VA/DoD Substance Use Disorders CPG). |
| 6. Avoid long-term opioid therapy for patients younger than 30 years of age secondary to higher risk of opioid use disorder and overdose. For patients younger than 30 years of age currently on long-term opioid therapy, we recommend close monitoring and consideration for tapering when risks exceed benefits (see Recommendations 14 and 17). |
Risk mitigation
| 7. Implement risk mitigation strategies after initiation of long-term opioid therapy, starting with an informed consent conversation covering the risks and benefits of opioid therapy as well as alternative therapies. The strategies and their frequency should be commensurate with risk factors and include: Ongoing, random urine drug testing (including appropriate confirmatory testing), checking state prescription drug monitoring programs, monitoring for overdose potential and suicidality, providing overdose education, and prescribing of naloxone rescue and accompanying education. |
| 8. Assess suicide risk when considering initiating or continuing long-term opioid therapy and intervening when necessary. |
| 9. Evaluate benefits of continued opioid therapy and risk for opioid-related adverse events at least every 3 months. |
Type, dose, follow-up, and taper of opioids
| 10. If prescribing opioids, prescribe the lowest dose of opioids as indicated by patient-specific risks and benefits. Note: There is no absolutely safe dose of opioids. |
| 11. As opioid dosage and risk increase, the VA and DoD recommend more frequent monitoring for adverse events including opioid use disorder and overdose. Note: Risks for opioid use disorder start at any dose and increase in a dose-dependent manner. Risks for overdose and death significantly increase at a range of 20 to 50 mg morphine equivalent daily dose. |
| 12. Avoid opioid doses greater than 90 mg morphine equivalent daily dose for treating chronic pain. Note: For patients who are currently prescribed doses greater than 90 mg morphine equivalent daily dose, evaluate for tapering to reduced dose or to discontinuation (see Recommendations 15 and 16). |
| 13. Avoid prescribing long-acting opioids for acute pain, as an as-needed medication, or on initiation of long-term opioid therapy. |
| 14. The VA and DoD recommend tapering to reduced dose or to discontinuation of long-term opioid therapy when risks of long-term opioid therapy outweigh benefits. Note: Abrupt discontinuation should be avoided unless required for immediate safety concerns. |
| 15. Individualize opioid tapering based on risk assessment and patient needs and characteristics. Note: There is insufficient evidence to recommend for or against specific tapering strategies and schedules. |
| 16. Use interdisciplinary care that addresses pain, substance use disorders, and/or mental health problems for patients presenting with high risk and/or aberrant behavior. |
| 17. Offer medication-assisted treatment for opioid use disorder to patients with chronic pain and opioid use disorder. Note:See the VA/DoD Clinical Practice Guideline for the Management of Substance Use Disorders. |
Opioid therapy for acute pain
| 18. Use alternatives to opioids for mild-to-moderate acute pain. The VA and DoD suggest use of multimodal pain care, including nonopioid medications as indicated when opioids are used for acute pain (weak strength). If take-home opioids are prescribed, the VA and DoD recommend that immediate-release opioids are used at the lowest effective dose with opioid therapy reassessment no later than 3 to 5 days to determine if adjustments or continuing opioid therapy is indicated. Note: Patient education about opioid risks and alternatives to opioid therapy should be offered. |
“This guideline is not intended as a standard of care and should not be used as such,” stated the work group. “Standards of care are determined on the basis of all clinical data available for an individual case and are subject to change as scientific knowledge and technology advances and patterns evolve. Today there is variation among state regulations, and this guideline does not cover the variety of ever-changing state regulations that may be pertinent. The ultimate judgment regarding a particular clinical procedure or treatment course must be made by the individual clinician, in light of the patient’s clinical presentation, patient preferences, and the available diagnostic and treatment options.”
Filed under: General Problems
Why don’t they just call these the ‘Suicide as a Solution for Chronic Pain Recommendations’ and be done with it.
I guess 22 veteran suicides a day isn’t enough, let’s find an official way to drive that number higher. Very cost effective. Compassion and humanity in our health care system is inefficient, and unnecessary. This should lighten their workload. Just move everybody straight to the Coroner’s office.
#opioidmyths
This publication is remarkable for talking out of both sides of the doctors’ mouths. Like the CDC Guidelines, this clinical guideline is represented as voluntary. Based on experience with the CDC Guidelines, we all know where that’s headed — this is a defacto STANDARD and it will be enforced as one.
I also consider the notion that this standard is “evidence based”, to be outright silly. It is no such thing. The evidence for restrictions on prescription opioids is very weak. Likewise, nowhere in this document is mentioned the wide range of opioid metabolism that one encounters in any patient population. There are tens of thousands of people in the US who are taking enough opioids to knock over a horse, without negative effects or risk of addiction. To get pain relief at all, they need daily doses well above 100 MMEDD, because they are poor metabolizers of opioids and/or anti-seizure meds sometimes used off-label for neuropathic pain. The only way I know of to detect such people is to run a blood test for the CYP-450 enzyme metabolism defect of opiates. But that doesn’t seem to be mentioned in this standard.
Like the CDC Guidelines, this more recent version suffers from reliance on very weak medical evidence — some of which may have been cherry-picked to support a preexisting anti-opioid agenda. Thus it is appropriate to call this standard by its proper name: BULL FEATHERS!
As a disabled veteran, I can assure you what this amounts to is pain management physicians simply refusing to prescribe any opiate pain relievers except in the most extreme cases. I was cut off several years ago, and at least in the state of Ohio, they don’t prescribe them. They do not care how bad you are suffering, and they do not care how destructive living with untreated chronic pain is to your life. They would rather see you confined to bed and/or a wheel chair than prescribe any opiate pain reliever. They also don’t care how many veterans commit suicide over untreated pain. A dead disabled veteran is one less benefit check they have to issue.
My god,,what has America come too???When forced Endurement of physical pain is prescribed to the very men who help save this countries freedoms,,,They are not even allowed to have the freedom of not being tortured in their own Country!!
Make no mistake about this being willful torture by a state agency,,For,the legal definition of Torture is;denial of effective medical care for severe physical pain by a state government entity.Forced endurement of severe physical pain by a state entity,, for the purpose of information to a 3 rds party,ie,u are now FORCED to see a shrink,ie,3rd party for information about your private medical needs,,Furthermore ,this is forced endurement of severe physical pain by a state entity,,,Like it or not,,this is legally torture committed by a state entity,,and they alll should be charge as such,,for the sentence for torture,is life in prison.,,,very appropriate for that is exactly what they are doing to us,,forcing us to live in a body w/severe physical pain ,w/no medically effective relief for physical pain caused by a medical condition,,,we should all charge these state employee’s w/torture,,,,,at a minimum,,THANK U FOR YOUR SERVICE!!!!!,maryw